I believe that the role-play aspect of Sarah seems fine and clearly the time taken to fill out the application shows a desire and commitment to the cause.
My concern and what I have seen of Sarah of in character is the lack of discussion or debating when decisions have been made by her in game. It seems to be a trend these days on Aurora that some of the heads use the archaic leadership style of put-up or shut-up. Some people seem to feel that a leader needs to be or have strong traits in this skill and it really grinds on me seeing this in game. The qualities of a good leader should demonstrate Honesty, Delegation, Assertiveness, A sense of humor, communication and the confidence to hold all these in check.
This is a game after all and I feel some heads really do just hinder the gaming experience for people, I have only being playing space station thirteen for about a week now and luckily found this server which apart from my concerns stated above is the best I have found so far.
For the reasons stated I am going to sat a -1