Apologies for the wait. After a few days to deliberate, we've decided to uphold the complaint from Evan.
While we don't find any of Union's reasoning to be in bad faith, some clarification is needed:
CMOs are allowed to view any and all medical records. They don't need to be directly involved with a patient, nor are there special protections for medical records barring non-medical, non-security personnel. Part of this is a gameplay concession—being that it would make it more frustrating for CMO players to involve themselves otherwise, not to mention a different system for holding psychiatric records—and the other is for the ship's benefit of not requiring something like a "head of psychology" or other associated role. The CMO, barring extreme circumstances that require a fax to external departments and/or CCIA, is the decision-maker in that regard. Lying to your boss about having access to them would have been either seen as a joke or a very severe mistake- please be careful not to go overboard like this in the future.
@StewardsCap Staff would like to see you play a more level-headed character. Not including this complaint, they've been arrested 4 times over the course of 20 rounds. With multiple charges in short order they're beginning to push the bounds of believability. You don't have to be a model character, but we'd like to see some development in that regard.
If there's nothing else, this will be closed and locked in 24 hours.