Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Soultheif96

Staff Complaint: Alberyk/Garnascus

Recommended Posts

BYOND Key: Soultheif96

Staff BYOND Key: Alberyk, Garnascus

Game ID: b3u-aM6c

Reason for complaint: I would like to contest the Command Whitelist Strip, decision made by Alberyk, based on Temporary Ban placed by Garnascus.

Evidence/logs/etc:

Based on expunging the charge of Manslaughter and Gross Negligence. Story in full is: Pod Survivor crashed onto the asteroid and being the EMT on call, I responded accordingly. There were multiple obstacles that I faced and cannot overcome without the use of a jetpack. Once I reached the survivor, it was reported by themself that their oxygen tank was at 40-50 kPa, therefore I knew they will die given the impassable terrain and lack of oxygen supplies I can provide. I decided against the survivor's wishes to push them off the asteroid to make their body recoverable, which turns out not to be the case due to needing to move themselves to make it so. I announced my actions to the CMO, who then called for security to arrest me on charges of Murder. I came back to the station to meet the security force, who I gave in for arrest on terms I hand over my equipment. During my processing, I ask that I provide my statement to the detective in order to receive a lesser sentence. Doing so convinced Marc Price (HoS) and Fernando Gonzales (CMO) to only charge me for what is discussed in beginning. I served the sentence.

After the round, I decided to expunge the charge against the wishes of other parties, therefore a rule violation and a temporary ban in discussion with Garnascus. I accepted the punishment and found myself in the wrong, to which I will admit that my actions were deemed necessary for a temporary ban.

Now, I wish to contest the aftermath of the temporary ban, which was a command whitelist strip. I have found this to be excessive and unnecessary. In turn, I made the application post not long ago in response and was closed. I was recommended to make a complaint. Here we are.

image.png.e62dcc4945dfaf7dbfbd8b33a861d734.png 

Additional remarks:

I would like to make this clear, I accepted my temporary ban as it was deemed necessary, but I do not accept the fact the whitelist was stripped. During my time as command, I have been actively getting feedback from the community to improve on my command play and it has changed my behavior on metagaming and powergaming. I have spoke with people on this matter and many vocalized that the whitelist strip was unwarranted and were confused. I have been sticking to my original intentions stated in the whitelist app long ago as they ring true for me and never had an issue with staff as a command player.

I would like the Command Whitelist to be returned back to me.

Involving people who were in the situation: @Brutishcrab51, @Resilynn, @CampinKiller.

Share this post


Link to post

Why did you put garn's name if you agree with his decision?

Now, if you read this: 

 

You may notice this:

"Receiving too many administrative actions.

The previous conditions are under the discretion of the team to enforce. If you disagree with the removal, create a staff complaint for others to review."

So, yes. You have a couple of notes and warnings, and coupled with the ban, that is pretty much too many administrative actions.

Share this post


Link to post

I do note that I have received too many administrative actions as discussed in Whitelist Applications Rules but I believe it was not justifiable enough to remove the command whitelist when I have been communicative and improving the behavior in relation to the expectations of a command player. I have been adamant on helping the community by teaching and making the rounds enjoyable from Captain/Head of Staff side of things and you can ask the community of that and get a similar response to what Resilyn stated. 

If there is a warning or a note that can be pointed out as a concern and validation, I would like to hear it and take it into consideration. Please do note that I have been trying to improve throughout my ten months here.

Share this post


Link to post

The thing is, garn did consider what you did, taking in consideration your notes and warnings, worth of a ban. There is really a escalation in punishments, and your case was severe enough to deserve a temporary ban. 

Sorry, but can't really make an exception when the whitelists guidelines are clear on this. If any whitelisted player reaches the point of being banned, they are also being whitelist stripped.

Share this post


Link to post

What are your suggestions to help remedy this and perhaps regain the whitelist again given the administration actions appear to not shine lightly on this?

Share this post


Link to post

As I explained in your application, you are free to reapply in some weeks, 3 or 4 should be enough. If you do not break any rules, we can consider a trial.

Share this post


Link to post
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...