Jump to content

Staff Complaint - Pratepresident


Recommended Posts

BYOND Key: TheNewOrleans

Staff BYOND Key: @Pratepresidenten

Game ID: Game before b1U-cyYZ

Reason for complaint: Reaction out of proportion from Prate, when I didn't do anything wrong. I will explain everything in the logs.

Evidence/logs/etc:

So, I joined a round where transfer shuttle already left, I walk inside the Research Department and I find an officer in there, and the RD in the room beside. The officer wanted to get through, so I opened the door, and he batoned the ass of the RD without saying a word. When I saw this, I pushed him once, since he was batoning my boss, with no other officers around, without saying anything, without trying to cuff him prior to the batoning. There was nothing but batoning from the officer. So I pushed him once, disarming him and grabbing the baton. I could have done many things once I had the baton with me, but, applying logic, the best thing was walking back a bit, and trying to speak with the officer, to de-escalate the situation. Did he say anything? No, he didn't. He shot me multiple times without saying a word while I tried to write 'Stop' while avoiding getting shots. At that moment I ahelped. He shot me THE FULL magazine. Then he said DROP IT, MOTHERFUCKER. And shot me more with the tazer while I didn't have time to reply.

67e2fb26e5179cf278d82c957756e27b.png

50484a05f51df6ca01804552663751c2.png

 

I ahelped about it and I was told those were rubbers, he wasn't killing me, and it was okay since I stopped an arrest. Imo the fact that no words were said by the officer shows a lot about him, only going pew pew. once I was downed after a full rubber magazine (not even the tazer, which his non-lethal, he shot me rubbers which have another name, can't remember). And then he banged me against a window, making me bleed. 

54fa5afbebef31478757978319629889.png

Prate said I didn't roleplay the pain I was suffering, then explain this

a0ec0fd7f7d127ec90528718a7fdc4e5.png

ee682fa6cc3da455b5db55a2e082d33a.png

My character was kneeled next to the Director who was unresponsive

f9c6146da9aaee985b35e619ed154e4f.png

And the psycho officer batoned me again, when I was bleeding, and giving my back to him

bd373679eaf134e5f4e9438c5141e0a9.png

848502866a501ac7fa2d519a7f669736.png

@Aboshedab was the one handling my ahelp, and this is what he said about the situation

b90342b1895c8770b41c6e064b11e3d0.png

Which was acceptable since I did that (without knowing it), Abos deemed it okay so I accepted it.

My character was stumbling, trying to help the Director, to protect him, but without being hostile in an active way, since she was in a lot of pain, but the officer had killed someone already. All the purpose for my character was trying to keep them both alive, since, as I said, the officer already killed someone and was acting like a psycopath.

2f444492ca295753246bb3a1a962cb0e.png

193e1b8793cb611477476c01294395d6.png

By the way, Abos deemed both his actions and mine acceptable.

e057b43ab16bdcf75de17b635b0a9bfc.png

Then the officer healed me, and also the medibot  and later in medbay I tried to escape cuffs.

 

And, the outcome of all of this is that the next round, Prate bwoinked me and applied a permaban after speaking a bit with me and taking a long time to gather info

 

So

*I intervened in an arrest to stop a batoning with in my character eyes was brutality, since the officer didn't even try a peaceful approach or say a word, by taking the baton away, not even hitting the officer or anything

*The officer shot me like a psycopath after having killed someone

*I roleplay the pain quite more than people usually do

*I try to protect the Director from being killed

*I am permabanned

What am I missing? 

Additional remarks: Abo deemed actions acceptable that round, and I don't know why, out of nowhere Prate bwoinked me and applied the permaban.

Edited by TheOrleans
Link to comment
45 minutes ago, DRagO said:

Going to put this here for whoever takes this, The permban was applied as a condition of the OP's secban appeal if they show improper behavior

 

I wasn't even using a security character and the permaban was applied cause I had a permaban lifted not long ago

Edited by TheOrleans
Link to comment
42 minutes ago, Aboshedab said:

Inaccurate. I cleared the actions of the Officer. There was intention to handle your actions but I had to leave, handing it over to Prat, which he got the following round. 

You said 'I don't see any issue here'

But okay

Link to comment
1 hour ago, TheOrleans said:

You said 'I don't see any issue here'

But okay

Yes, in regards to your ahelp, the issue being the conduct of the officer. Your ahelp outlined an issue which I declared not to be an issue, as the action of the officer was a response to how you acted. You're arguing semantics when I'm telling you what was meant. Even if I intended to clear everything as fine, Prat can still overrule my decision by virtue of them being the admin and myself being the trial.

This should be all the logs on the situation, I found some in your images to be lacking, such as the line where you tried to get out of your restraints. 

Spoiler

[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stutters, "B-B-B-Bom-mb."
[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stutters, "H-H-Hit-t us-s."
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "Lie down!"
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "Both of you!"
[F] Gordon Dutch exclaims, "Or I'll shoot!"
[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stutters, "A N-NUK-K-K-KE J-J-J-JUS-ST-T H-HIT-T US-S-S-S!"
[F] Gordon Dutch asks, "Are you dumb!?"
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "No, not that shit again!"
Ziiq'Luu Xrim telepathically says to Gordon Dutch: Drop the gun. You know you want to. Drop it. Just do it.
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "Go to hell!"
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "Where is Armstrong!"
Ziiq'Luu Xrim telepathically says to Gordon Dutch: Drop the gun. Do it. Drop it.
[F] Lyanna Haley asks, "Hm?"
[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stammers, "He d-died-d!"
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "And you're next if you don't lie the fuck down right now!"
[F] Lyanna Haley asks, "Hello?"
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "What's."
[F] Lyanna Haley asks, "Going on?"
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) stunned with the stunbaton      he (Ziiq'Luu Xrim) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) stunned with the stunbaton      he (Ziiq'Luu Xrim) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
ATTACK: (Lyanna Haley) disarmed Gordon Dutch  (JMP)
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) stunned with the stunbaton      he (Ziiq'Luu Xrim) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
ATTACK:Gordon Dutch) shot (/obj/item/projectile/bullet/pistol/rubber) Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "Stop."
ATTACK(Gordon Dutch) Gordon Dutch is aiming at Lyanna Haley with .45 pistol. (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) Gordon Dutch is no longer aiming at Lyanna Haley with .45 pistol. (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) shot (/obj/item/projectile/bullet/pistol/rubber) (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "HEY."
Gordon Dutch aims .45 pistol at Lyanna Haley!Gordon Dutch pulls the trigger reflexively!
Gordon Dutch fires .45 pistol!
ATTACK: Gordon Dutch is no longer aiming at Lyanna Haley with .45 pistol. Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
Gordon Dutch lowers .45 pistol.
Gordon Dutch fires .45 pistol!Gordon Dutch puts .45 pistol into the security belt.
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "drop it!"
Gordon Dutch aims the taser gun at Lyanna Haley!
Gordon Dutch pulls the trigger reflexively!
Gordon Dutch fires the taser gun!
Gordon Dutch lowers the taser gun.
Lyanna Haley screams!
Lyanna Haley is hit by the electrode in the chest!

ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) stunned with the stunbaton      he (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: DISARM) (JMP)
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) stunned with the stunbaton      he (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: DISARM) (JMP)
Gordon Dutch is attempting to put handcuffs on Lyanna Haley!

Gordon Dutch has put handcuffs on Lyanna Haley!
Gordon Dutch puts the stunbaton into the security belt.
Gordon Dutch has grabbed Lyanna Haley passively!
Gordon Dutch pins Lyanna Haley down to the ground (now hands)!
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "motherfucker."
Gordon Dutch has reinforced his grip on Lyanna Haley (now neck)!
Lyanna Haley resists!
Lyanna Haley attempts to slip out of the handcuffs!
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "Gh.."
Gordon Dutch crushes Lyanna Haley against the reinforced window!
Gordon Dutch bangs against the reinforced window!
[F] Lyanna Haley shouts, "Leave me be!"
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "HEY."

Lyanna Haley stutters, "I... I am-m... b-bl-l-leedin-ng-g-g.."
Lyanna Haley looks at herself
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "shouldn't have fucked around."
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "D-Di...d-dir-rec-ct-tor-r.."
[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stammers, "Y-You s-sh-houl-ld-d-dn-n't-t hav-v-v-ve hur-rt-t h-he."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "and you stop right there."
Ziiq'Luu Xrim touches their fingers to their temple.
Gordon Dutch puts the taser gun into the security belt.
Gordon Dutch removes the magazine (.45 rubber) from .45 pistol.
Ziiq'Luu Xrim telepathically says to Gordon Dutch: Drop the gun.
Gordon Dutch inserts the magazine (.45 rubber) into .45 pistol.
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "I am... bleedig..."
[F] Gordon Dutch exclaims, "stop it!"
[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stutters, "Y-Y-You k-kil-l-ll-led-d EM-MILIO!"
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "I don't want to die... Director..."
Ziiq'Luu Xrim touches their fingers to their temple.
Lyanna Haley cries
Ziiq'Luu Xrim telepathically says to Gordon Dutch: Turn the gun on yourself, DO IT. KILL YOURSELF.
Gordon Dutch holds his head.
Ziiq'Luu Xrim touches their fingers to their temple.
Ziiq'Luu Xrim telepathically says to Gordon Dutch: Turn it against yourself! Put it in your mouth!
Ziiq'Luu Xrim can no longer stand, collapsing!
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "Di...director."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "both of you."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "lie down."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "Now."
Lyanna Haley kneels
[F] Lyanna Haley asks, "Director...?"
Gordon Dutch puts .45 pistol into the security belt.
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "Don't... don't go.."
Lyanna Haley has been prodded in the upper body with the stunbaton by Gordon Dutch!
Lyanna Haley has been prodded with the stunbaton by Gordon Dutch!
Lyanna Haley has been prodded in the upper body with the stunbaton by Gordon Dutch!
Lyanna Haley has been prodded with the stunbaton by Gordon Dutch!
Lyanna Haley screams!
Lyanna Haley slumps to the ground, too weak to continue fighting..
Gordon Dutch puts the stunbaton into the security belt.
Gordon Dutch is attempting to put handcuffs on Ziiq'Luu Xrim!
Gordon Dutch has put handcuffs on Ziiq'Luu Xrim!

Lyanna Haley is having trouble keeping their eyes open.
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "L-L-L-Le...l-l-l-leav-ve h-him-m b-be.."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "you fuck off."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "you don't even know what's happening."
Gordon Dutch has grabbed Ziiq'Luu Xrim passively!
Gordon Dutch starts treating Ziiq'Luu Xrim's upper body.
Gordon Dutch bandages a puncture wound on Ziiq'Luu Xrim's upper body.
Gordon Dutch places a bruise patch over a tiny bruise on Ziiq'Luu Xrim's upper body.
Gordon Dutch starts salving wounds on Ziiq'Luu Xrim's upper body.
Gordon Dutch salved wounds on Ziiq'Luu Xrim's upper body.
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "Why would you fucking do that!"
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "D-Di...r-r-ret-t-tor-r.."
ATTACK: Gordon Dutch  has thrown Lyanna Haleyfrom tile at 95, 116, 4 in area the Research and Development with the target tile at 97, 117, 4 in area the Research and Development (JMP)
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "Y-Y-You k-kil-ll-led-d h-him-m.."
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "Stay!"
[F] Lyanna Haley stammers, "<b-b-b>L-Leav-ve h-him b-be!</b>"
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "Do as you're fucking told, broad!"
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "H-He's-s a g-good..."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "I am going to hit you again."
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "I'm-m-m b-bl-leed-din-ng-g al-lr-read-dy-y..."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "if you do not let me leave with the both of you."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "yes."
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "I am trying to fix that, but you're being retarded!"
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "Leave the director..."
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "She's a good woman.."
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "Still has a pulse!"
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "now go!"
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "oh my god."
[F] Lyanna Haley exclaims, "You're going to kill him!"
ATTACK: Gordon Dutch) attempted to remove PDA-Lyanna Haley (Scientist) from (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: GRAB) (JMP)
[F] Medibot says, "Hey, Lyanna Haley! Hold on, I'm coming."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "I swear to god, woman."
[F] Lyanna Haley yells, "Leav me be you rapist!"

[F] Lyanna Haley yells, "Gha!"

 

Link to comment
2 minutes ago, Aboshedab said:

Yes, in regards to your ahelp, the issue being the conduct of the officer. Your ahelp outlined an issue which I declared not to be an issue, as the action of the officer was a response to how you acted. You're arguing semantics when I'm telling you what was meant. Even if I intended to clear everything as fine, Prat can still overrule my decision by virtue of them being the admin and myself being the trial.

This should be all the logs on the situation, I found some in your images to be lacking, such as the line where you tried to get out of your restraints. 

  Reveal hidden contents

[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stutters, "B-B-B-Bom-mb."
[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stutters, "H-H-Hit-t us-s."
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "Lie down!"
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "Both of you!"
[F] Gordon Dutch exclaims, "Or I'll shoot!"
[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stutters, "A N-NUK-K-K-KE J-J-J-JUS-ST-T H-HIT-T US-S-S-S!"
[F] Gordon Dutch asks, "Are you dumb!?"
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "No, not that shit again!"
Ziiq'Luu Xrim telepathically says to Gordon Dutch: Drop the gun. You know you want to. Drop it. Just do it.
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "Go to hell!"
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "Where is Armstrong!"
Ziiq'Luu Xrim telepathically says to Gordon Dutch: Drop the gun. Do it. Drop it.
[F] Lyanna Haley asks, "Hm?"
[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stammers, "He d-died-d!"
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "And you're next if you don't lie the fuck down right now!"
[F] Lyanna Haley asks, "Hello?"
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "What's."
[F] Lyanna Haley asks, "Going on?"
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) stunned with the stunbaton      he (Ziiq'Luu Xrim) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) stunned with the stunbaton      he (Ziiq'Luu Xrim) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
ATTACK: (Lyanna Haley) disarmed Gordon Dutch  (JMP)
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) stunned with the stunbaton      he (Ziiq'Luu Xrim) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
ATTACK:Gordon Dutch) shot (/obj/item/projectile/bullet/pistol/rubber) Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "Stop."
ATTACK(Gordon Dutch) Gordon Dutch is aiming at Lyanna Haley with .45 pistol. (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) Gordon Dutch is no longer aiming at Lyanna Haley with .45 pistol. (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) shot (/obj/item/projectile/bullet/pistol/rubber) (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "HEY."
Gordon Dutch aims .45 pistol at Lyanna Haley!Gordon Dutch pulls the trigger reflexively!
Gordon Dutch fires .45 pistol!
ATTACK: Gordon Dutch is no longer aiming at Lyanna Haley with .45 pistol. Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: HELP) (JMP)
Gordon Dutch lowers .45 pistol.
Gordon Dutch fires .45 pistol!Gordon Dutch puts .45 pistol into the security belt.
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "drop it!"
Gordon Dutch aims the taser gun at Lyanna Haley!
Gordon Dutch pulls the trigger reflexively!
Gordon Dutch fires the taser gun!
Gordon Dutch lowers the taser gun.
Lyanna Haley screams!
Lyanna Haley is hit by the electrode in the chest!

ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) stunned with the stunbaton      he (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: DISARM) (JMP)
ATTACK: (Gordon Dutch) stunned with the stunbaton      he (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: DISARM) (JMP)
Gordon Dutch is attempting to put handcuffs on Lyanna Haley!

Gordon Dutch has put handcuffs on Lyanna Haley!
Gordon Dutch puts the stunbaton into the security belt.
Gordon Dutch has grabbed Lyanna Haley passively!
Gordon Dutch pins Lyanna Haley down to the ground (now hands)!
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "motherfucker."
Gordon Dutch has reinforced his grip on Lyanna Haley (now neck)!
Lyanna Haley resists!
Lyanna Haley attempts to slip out of the handcuffs!
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "Gh.."
Gordon Dutch crushes Lyanna Haley against the reinforced window!
Gordon Dutch bangs against the reinforced window!
[F] Lyanna Haley shouts, "Leave me be!"
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "HEY."

Lyanna Haley stutters, "I... I am-m... b-bl-l-leedin-ng-g-g.."
Lyanna Haley looks at herself
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "shouldn't have fucked around."
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "D-Di...d-dir-rec-ct-tor-r.."
[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stammers, "Y-You s-sh-houl-ld-d-dn-n't-t hav-v-v-ve hur-rt-t h-he."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "and you stop right there."
Ziiq'Luu Xrim touches their fingers to their temple.
Gordon Dutch puts the taser gun into the security belt.
Gordon Dutch removes the magazine (.45 rubber) from .45 pistol.
Ziiq'Luu Xrim telepathically says to Gordon Dutch: Drop the gun.
Gordon Dutch inserts the magazine (.45 rubber) into .45 pistol.
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "I am... bleedig..."
[F] Gordon Dutch exclaims, "stop it!"
[F] Ziiq'Luu Xrim stutters, "Y-Y-You k-kil-l-ll-led-d EM-MILIO!"
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "I don't want to die... Director..."
Ziiq'Luu Xrim touches their fingers to their temple.
Lyanna Haley cries
Ziiq'Luu Xrim telepathically says to Gordon Dutch: Turn the gun on yourself, DO IT. KILL YOURSELF.
Gordon Dutch holds his head.
Ziiq'Luu Xrim touches their fingers to their temple.
Ziiq'Luu Xrim telepathically says to Gordon Dutch: Turn it against yourself! Put it in your mouth!
Ziiq'Luu Xrim can no longer stand, collapsing!
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "Di...director."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "both of you."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "lie down."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "Now."
Lyanna Haley kneels
[F] Lyanna Haley asks, "Director...?"
Gordon Dutch puts .45 pistol into the security belt.
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "Don't... don't go.."
Lyanna Haley has been prodded in the upper body with the stunbaton by Gordon Dutch!
Lyanna Haley has been prodded with the stunbaton by Gordon Dutch!
Lyanna Haley has been prodded in the upper body with the stunbaton by Gordon Dutch!
Lyanna Haley has been prodded with the stunbaton by Gordon Dutch!
Lyanna Haley screams!
Lyanna Haley slumps to the ground, too weak to continue fighting..
Gordon Dutch puts the stunbaton into the security belt.
Gordon Dutch is attempting to put handcuffs on Ziiq'Luu Xrim!
Gordon Dutch has put handcuffs on Ziiq'Luu Xrim!

Lyanna Haley is having trouble keeping their eyes open.
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "L-L-L-Le...l-l-l-leav-ve h-him-m b-be.."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "you fuck off."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "you don't even know what's happening."
Gordon Dutch has grabbed Ziiq'Luu Xrim passively!
Gordon Dutch starts treating Ziiq'Luu Xrim's upper body.
Gordon Dutch bandages a puncture wound on Ziiq'Luu Xrim's upper body.
Gordon Dutch places a bruise patch over a tiny bruise on Ziiq'Luu Xrim's upper body.
Gordon Dutch starts salving wounds on Ziiq'Luu Xrim's upper body.
Gordon Dutch salved wounds on Ziiq'Luu Xrim's upper body.
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "Why would you fucking do that!"
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "D-Di...r-r-ret-t-tor-r.."
ATTACK: Gordon Dutch  has thrown Lyanna Haleyfrom tile at 95, 116, 4 in area the Research and Development with the target tile at 97, 117, 4 in area the Research and Development (JMP)
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "Y-Y-You k-kil-ll-led-d h-him-m.."
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "Stay!"
[F] Lyanna Haley stammers, "<b-b-b>L-Leav-ve h-him b-be!</b>"
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "Do as you're fucking told, broad!"
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "H-He's-s a g-good..."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "I am going to hit you again."
[F] Lyanna Haley stutters, "I'm-m-m b-bl-leed-din-ng-g al-lr-read-dy-y..."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "if you do not let me leave with the both of you."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "yes."
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "I am trying to fix that, but you're being retarded!"
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "Leave the director..."
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "She's a good woman.."
[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "Still has a pulse!"
[F] Gordon Dutch yells, "now go!"
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "oh my god."
[F] Lyanna Haley exclaims, "You're going to kill him!"
ATTACK: Gordon Dutch) attempted to remove PDA-Lyanna Haley (Scientist) from (Lyanna Haley) (INTENT: GRAB) (JMP)
[F] Medibot says, "Hey, Lyanna Haley! Hold on, I'm coming."
[F] Gordon Dutch says, "I swear to god, woman."
[F] Lyanna Haley yells, "Leav me be you rapist!"

[F] Lyanna Haley yells, "Gha!"

 

I explained I tried to get out of my restraints later on medbay

Link to comment

Hello, I was the officer. A lot of the info in your OP is either misinformation or blatantly untrue. If you are not certain of the validity of something, you should not state it as fact. I will cover them here:


 

I did fire the entire magazine of seven .45 rubber rounds AT you, only one or two rounds hit you. And you continued to run away with my equipment, so logically I was going to continue trying to stop you. That's when I told you to "drop it" (I did not say "drop it, motherfucker") and aimed my taser at you. You kept moving, or trying to speak, or messed with your inventory or something, causing the trigger reflex.

You did not drop to the floor until after I tased you - obviously the one or two rubber rounds were not enough.

Your screenshots are extremely cherrypicked, the logs Abo posted are much more accurate. I won't go into my own opinions on that but I will say that you failed to show the part where you tried to resist both out of my grip and my cuffs after having ran away from me and directly intervening the detention of a terrorist, of which had just murdered at least one officer (could have been a detective, I can't remember, it is a person regardless), and so I smashed you against the window. Is that excessive from an IC standpoint? Yeah, Gordon would have been arrested for that if it was standard operation. It was not, though. It was a tense and stressful situation from his perspective, especially considering one of his colleagues was likely dead on the lower level.

I did not kill Emillio, that was actually only the second time in total Gordon had ever encountered them that entire round. I have no idea why they were so wounded. The RD was wounded either because they bombed themselves or because Jesse Armstrong fought them in xenobio/toxins on the lower level, possibly both.

You failed to show where you were basically in some kind of weird trance-like state trying to defend the RD for... I actually have no idea. You said you were protecting them because they were your boss, but I can tell you right now I would not take bullets for my Cell Lead at the injection molding plant I work at in real life. That's not really relevant, but serves as a nice segue into my closing point.

 

Having taken all of this into account, this is the part where you walked in:

[F] Gordon Dutch shouts, "And you're next if you don't lie the fuck down right now!"
[F] Lyanna Haley asks, "Hello?"
[F] Lyanna Haley says, "What's."
[F] Lyanna Haley asks, "Going on?"

How could you have possibly made an informed decision at this point? And might I add, there is absolutely no logic in disarming a security officer for any reason at any point in time, especially considering you had just arrived. You say it was logical to take the baton and run away without "escalating," but you already escalated when you showed up out of nowhere and assisted a terrorist. And if you had known they were a terrorist, you would have stayed back and did nothing and watched as Gordon detained the two dying individuals and escorted them to safety, which is exactly what he intended to do. I say it was not logical to do anything. You should have stayed back and watched. You arrived and made a harebrained decision based off of some kind of flawed judgement, I really don't know. I just can't wrap my head around why you think it would be appropriate to disarm a security officer mid-arrest and expect them to just stop and have a conversation with you on why you decided to forcefully take their equipment from them.

 

And then, despite all of that, you continued your fervent defense of the RD, body blocking Gordon from trying to get his job done, trying to resist out of your cuffs multiple times, generally just acting strangely in regards to the RD, and because of your distraction, Emillio died and the RD nearly died. Despite an obvious show of force and direction, you did not follow instructions. Just like Abo said, not every situation is resolved with words, and you surrendered your ability to talk that situation out when you went hands-on with an officer performing an arrest. And if your defense to that is, "well I didn't know Gordon was making an arrest, I didn't know the RD was so dangerous, I didn't know Jesse Armstrong was undoubtedly dead or dying," all you are doing is making your own argument worse because that proves you went into the situation uninformed and making rash decisions.

 

Considering your history of permanent bans, job bans, warnings, and general notes (not even counting the ones from last year or the year before, most of your really bad notes are recent) I believe Prate was 100% justified in applying a permanent ban. This is a serious lapse of judgement, and it is apparently commonplace for you. It is my opinion that no wrongdoing has occurred except for your own. The original ahelp could probably have been handled better, but the staff team is not perfect either and that was a very busy round ending.

Edited by CakeIsOssim
Clarifying some information.
Link to comment
Quote

I did fire the entire magazine of seven .45 rubber rounds AT you, only one or two rounds hit you. And you continued to run away with my equipment, so logically I was going to continue trying to stop you. That's when I told you to "drop it" (I did not say "drop it, motherfucker") and aimed my taser at you. You kept moving, or trying to speak, or messed with your inventory or something, causing the trigger reflex.

1- You shot like a psycopath at me and said ''drop it'' after I was already shot multiple times. You are the one trying to explain things in a false way, since you started aiming at me when I was already running, after having shot me MULTIPLE TIMES with rubbers (which aren't non-lethals, but less-than-lethals) before starting to aim.

16 minutes ago, CakeIsOssim said:

You did not drop to the floor until after I tased you - obviously the one or two rubber rounds were not enough.

2- I was ahelping, I didn't move when you said 'drop it', and you didn't even give time for me to react or write, since you were acting like a psycopath and if you want to act that way you can go to a griefing server.

Quote

Your screenshots are extremely cherrypicked, the logs Abo posted are much more accurate. I won't go into my own opinions on that but I will say that you failed to show the part where you tried to resist both out of my grip and my cuffs after having ran away from me and directly intervening the detention of a terrorist, of which had just murdered at least one officer (could have been a detective, I can't remember, it is a person regardless)

3- The screenshots show nearly everything, and I explained that I resisted in medbay. There is ONE, ONLY ONE RESIST INTENT TO GET OUT OF THE CUFFS which I missed since I didn't see it. And when you press your arrow keys when grabbed, it auto-resists.

4- You are writing a LOT OF OOC INFORMATION I LACKED. And since in game, canonly, a RD would never be a terrorist, you are suggesting me to metagame.

Quote

I did not kill Emillio, that was actually only the second time in total Gordon had ever encountered them that entire round. I have no idea why they were so wounded. The RD was wounded either because they bombed themselves or because Jesse Armstrong fought them in xenobio/toxins on the lower level, possibly both.

5- That's information I didn't know ICly. Who would you believe? A Research Director, or a officer who is batoning and shooting people without saying a word like a real psycopath?

Quote

You failed to show where you were basically in some kind of weird trance-like state trying to defend the RD for... I actually have no idea. You said you were protecting them because they were your boss, but I can tell you right now I would not take bullets for my Cell Lead at the injection molding plant I work at in real life. That's not really relevant, but serves as a nice segue into my closing point.

6- I didn't take any bullets for him. You acted like a psycopath shooting at me like that, that's all.

Quote

How could you have possibly made an informed decision at this point? And might I add, there is absolutely no logic in disarming a security officer for any reason at any point in time, especially considering you had just arrived. You say it was logical to take the baton and run away without "escalating," but you already escalated when you showed up out of nowhere and assisted a terrorist. And if you had known they were a terrorist, you would have stayed back and did nothing and watched as Gordon detained the two dying individuals and escorted them to safety, which is exactly what he intended to do. I say it was not logical to do anything. You should have stayed back and watched. You arrived and made a harebrained decision based off of some kind of flawed judgement, I really don't know. I just can't wrap my head around why you think it would be appropriate to disarm a security officer mid-arrest and expect them to just stop and have a conversation with you on why you decided to forcefully take their equipment from them.

7- I opened the door for you, remember that. Cause I had no information, so I helped you. The moment you start batoning his ass without trying to cuff him or trying to speak, you are giving out a LOT of information buddy.

Quote

And then, despite all of that, you continued your fervent defense of the RD, body blocking Gordon from trying to get his job done, trying to resist out of your cuffs multiple times, generally just acting strangely in regards to the RD, and because of your distraction, Emillio died and the RD nearly died. Despite an obvious show of force and direction, you did not follow instructions.

8- Totally false, I only resisted once in the very beginning (mistake since I thought you were grabbing me, not cuffed), and never again until medbay, as the logs show. They died because you acted like a psycopath. And I acted like you act when you see a psycopath, you try to defend yourself.

Quote

Considering your history of permanent bans, job bans, warnings, and general notes (not even counting the ones from last year or the year before, most of your really bad notes are recent) I believe Prate was 100% justified in applying a permanent ban. This is a serious lapse of judgement, and it is apparently commonplace for you. It is my opinion that no wrongdoing has occurred except for your own. The original ahelp could probably have been handled better, but the staff team is not perfect either and that was a very busy round ending.

9- You are no one to judge me, the punishment or my story, buddy, you are just a griefer.

Edited by TheOrleans
Posted before without having it completed
Link to comment

I am a trial moderator just like Abo. I was a moderator for a year previously. Yes, it is my job to judge both your history and your punishment.

 

You also just said exactly what I told you would make your argument worse for yourself. All of that OOC information could have been gained IC if you had stood back and watched for even just thirty seconds. And you keep getting hung up on this "without a word" argument despite that not being the case. You were not present for the words, which is also bad for your argument.

I am not going to have a pissing match here on these posts, either. I have made my peace, and it is that you remain permanently banned from Aurora due to poor judgement, a history of validhunting, a history of powergaming, and a long history of poor decisions in general, of which this is just another.

Link to comment
11 minutes ago, CakeIsOssim said:

I am a trial moderator just like Abo. I was a moderator for a year previously. Yes, it is my job to judge both your history and your punishment.

 

You also just said exactly what I told you would make your argument worse for yourself. All of that OOC information could have been gained IC if you had stood back and watched for even just thirty seconds. And you keep getting hung up on this "without a word" argument despite that not being the case. You were not present for the words, which is also bad for your argument.

I am not going to have a pissing match here on these posts, either. I have made my peace, and it is that you remain permanently banned from Aurora due to poor judgement, a history of validhunting, a history of powergaming, and a long history of poor decisions in general, of which this is just another.

Re-read my post.

Your mod status is not shown in the forums, and well, now I understand a lot of stuff.

Your peace means nothing since you are the one involved in this staff complaint, and I'm complaining a second admin decision. You have already made very clear that you are a greedy new mod who has serious problems in his life and wants to go around having people banned to feel powerful. You speak at me like that, you get the same. Man, if you are badly treated in your injection plant, don't bring it here buddy.

 

In the year I've been playing here, I've seen no mod nor admin speak like you have in this post.

 

PD: Don't compare yourself with Abo, you sound ridiculous.

Edited by TheOrleans
Link to comment

I don't think any part of my replies were disrespectful. And you have now resorted to personal attacks. If there were any doubts about closing this complaint and denying any of your future ban appeals should you choose to make them, I think they have just been proven baseless.

 

Edit: it's also extremely convenient that you are going back and editing your posts to continue to defame me. I am not going to challenge this any more. I rest my case.

Edited by CakeIsOssim
Link to comment
11 minutes ago, TheOrleans said:

Re-read my post.

Your mod status is not shown in the forums, and well, now I understand a lot of stuff.

Your peace means nothing since you are the one involved in this staff complaint, and I'm complaining a second admin decision. You have already made very clear that you are a greedy new mod who has serious problems in his life and wants to go around having people banned to feel powerful. You speak at me like that, you get the same. Man, if you are badly treated in your injection plant, don't bring it here buddy.

 

In the year I've been playing here, I've seen no mod nor admin speak like you have in this post.

 

PD: Don't compare yourself with Abo, you sound ridiculous.

Do not insult staff on the forums. You know better than this.  

Link to comment
4 minutes ago, CakeIsOssim said:

I don't think any part of my replies were disrespectful. And you have now resorted to personal attacks. If there were any doubts about closing this complaint and denying any of your future ban appeals should you choose to make them, I think they have just been proven baseless.

You are showing everyone the vicious person you are with this.

3 minutes ago, Shadow7889 said:

Do not insult staff on the forums. You know better than this.  

This is the first time I have ever, EVER, disrespected someone OOCly like this. Not just staff, anyone. This is a game in the end, a community, and I appreciate a lot of them, and the staff team is made of excellent people. I've never been spoken to this by anyone, from Garnascus to the newest Trial Mod. And anyone who has spoken to me can assure you how respectful and kind I am.

Link to comment
7 hours ago, CakeIsOssim said:

You also just said exactly what I told you would make your argument worse for yourself. All of that OOC information could have been gained IC if you had stood back and watched for even just thirty seconds. And you keep getting hung up on this "without a word" argument despite that not being the case. You were not present for the words, which is also bad for your argument.

This here is essentially the main issue I had with the entire ordeal. As prior issues were that you do things without fully thinking it through, rushing into situations with zero intel, most likely getting yourself trashed in the process, and most of the times, you defy your pain either to fulfill a vendetta or in this case, to protect this person you had no heavy ties to.

The basis of your argument was that antags arent canon, hence noone is evil, yet you assumed the officer was evil, and the RD was not, even when it was the other way around this time. So you set out to stop this "unlawful assault" in an attempt to defuse the situation, which only made it worse.

As I told you over DMs and ahelps, you need to take a more passive stance and observe before passing judgement and interacting. Even to ahelp if you were uncertain if something was valid or not. You dont always have to play the hero and jump in face first on something you perceive as bad, as its very likely you bite you in the ass and be wrong altogether.

Link to comment
1 hour ago, Pratepresidenten said:

This here is essentially the main issue I had with the entire ordeal. As prior issues were that you do things without fully thinking it through, rushing into situations with zero intel, most likely getting yourself trashed in the process, and most of the times, you defy your pain either to fulfill a vendetta or in this case, to protect this person you had no heavy ties to.

The basis of your argument was that antags arent canon, hence noone is evil, yet you assumed the officer was evil, and the RD was not, even when it was the other way around this time. So you set out to stop this "unlawful assault" in an attempt to defuse the situation, which only made it worse.

As I told you over DMs and ahelps, you need to take a more passive stance and observe before passing judgement and interacting. Even to ahelp if you were uncertain if something was valid or not. You dont always have to play the hero and jump in face first on something you perceive as bad, as its very likely you bite you in the ass and be wrong altogether.

Actually I assumed that the officer was NOT evil, hence the reason I opened the door for him to get to the RD. I assumed the officer had something to do with the RD and I made it easy for him. 

At that point all the information I had is that the officer was trying to get to the RD and the RD was behind a door.

 

Then, once the door was opened, the officer started batoning the RD like a madman, without any words or prior action. At this point I already have information: The officer who I just helped is batoning my boss, a valuable head of staff, without having said any word or having tried to cuff him peacefully or anything.

 

So, now I had information. This officer is acting like a madman, and I just helped him, I feel bad about it.

 

I push him (which is not even considered assault), and take his baton away to stop the beating. Once the baton was in my hand, I moved back in order to show that I didn't want to hurt him.

What was the thing I expected to happen (OOCly)? He would have aimed at me and I would have asked him to calm down and dropped the baton.

What happened? He reacted like a psycopath shooting less-than-lethals on me.

Who could have expected that an officer shoots a full magazine of rubbers at someone who is clearly disengaging, right?

Link to comment

I know I wasn't actually in-round for this, so sorry about that, but no one else has seemed to bring this up yet. 

 
 
2
11 hours ago, TheOrleans said:
 
11 hours ago, TheOrleans said:

This is the first time I have ever, EVER, disrespected someone OOCly like this. Not just staff, anyone. This is a game in the end, a community, and I appreciate a lot of them, and the staff team is made of excellent people. I've never been spoken to this by anyone, from Garnascus to the newest Trial Mod. And anyone who has spoken to me can assure you how respectful and kind I am.

This is a complete lie, and you know it. You have a horrible attitude OOC. And a lot of people who have seen you can assure how rude you are.

Edited by FreshRefreshments
I dont know what the hell has happened to my post. Thanks new forums. The point of what i'm trying to quote is there, though.
Link to comment
48 minutes ago, FreshRefreshments said:

I know I wasn't actually in-round for this, so sorry about that, but no one else has seemed to bring this up yet. 

This is a complete lie, and you know it. You have a horrible attitude OOC. And a lot of people who have seen you can assure how rude you are.

That's a blatant lie and many staff members have posted here and no one disagreed with what I said regarding how respectful I am. I've made friends in this server and you don't get that by 'being so rude'.

However I got my warning for what I said to that 'trial mod', so you can be happy!

Edited by TheOrleans
Link to comment

Cake isn't a 'that trial mod'. Do some introspection. The things that are happening to you are happening for a reason, you have been given many chances to realize this. Literally every single ckey you interact with is a human being with goals, loved ones and their own problems.

It is understandable that you are upset, I would be too, Aurora is very important to me and I would do anything to stop myself from being booted out, same as you are now, but. This does not mean you can lash out and belittle people to make yourself seem better. Polishing a turd still nets you a turd.

Please, if you keep acting like this, you will not be coming back. And, if this gets denied, I hope you think long and hard about what has happened the past few months, and improve yourself as a person. See ya.

Link to comment

I will handle this. From at first, I don't see much issue with what the officer did, you stole the baton from him, stunning you is perfectly fine. 

Now, the deal is; you have a lot of notes and warnings, and you taking in consideration your behavior here and the security appeal, I do believe you did not really learn anything that staff tried to explain you in all those chances that you were given.

 

So, at this moment, I am leaning towards accepting prate's rulling here as valid.

Link to comment
25 minutes ago, Alberyk said:

I will handle this. From at first, I don't see much issue with what the officer did, you stole the baton from him, stunning you is perfectly fine. 

Now, the deal is; you have a lot of notes and warnings, and you taking in consideration your behavior here and the security appeal, I do believe you did not really learn anything that staff tried to explain you in all those chances that you were given.

 

So, at this moment, I am leaning towards accepting prate's rulling here as valid.

Indeed I guess that what Cake did is acceptable although aiming at me or saying something prior to shooting like a psycho would have been very appreciated (and would have stopped the interaction from escalating)

 

I have lot of notes and warnings and I've spoken to a trial mod here in a bad way, which are bad things, and I already got warned from them.

 

But you are not saying anything about the staff complaint itself or about why is it so unbelievable to stop an officer that acts like a madman from batoning your respectable boss. Again, my interaction in the arrest wasn't openly hostile or with an escalation purpose but the opposite. I tried to de-escalate. I would like to know what rule I broke.

This was believable conflict since I was trying to stop what in the eyes of my character was police brutality, without actually harming the officer who had a lot of means to finish the arrest. His actions are okay too since he overreacted but that's legit (considered in the rules, the situation was okay for overreacting), although I would say he powergamed (played to win), but that's not what I'm discussing, I want to know what rule I broke.

Edited by TheOrleans
Link to comment
×
×
  • Create New...