Lately I have noticed a trend happening among heads of staff. What specifically to do about it has given me no small amount of internal and indeed external conflict. The source of this conflict is the use of the emergency shuttle and what i think is and is not a good use for it. Rather than conceive some arbitrary hypothetical I will do my bet to outline a situation recently and how I handled it.
I will begin by disclosing that I was playing said round as a traitor. It was dead hour and if memory serves our crew was in the range of six to eleven. No engineers where present at the time of shift start. I decide to cause a little chaos and rig a few welder bombs in maint. If I recall I set off two or three. One near security, one by the janitors closet, and one by the toxins lab. This of course drives the crew into a panic about how to deal with this.
These events took about 40 or so minutes at which point the CMO at the time calls an emergency shuttle. I examined the station and found only one person had died, the vented areas also appeared contained. I PMed the CMO saying I didn't think a few bombs and no power was reasonable justification for an emergency shuttle. The CMO responded that no security where present to find the bomber and that without power we couldn't begin fixing the breaches.
Again, I was the traitor at the time responsible. I relayed my concerns to Jenna at the time about calling it so early. She seemed as conflicted as I was but that we should maybe let it happen. I decided to offer a compromise, I would admin-recall the shuttle until the 1 hour mark and if the situation didn't improve I could call another one. An engineer eventually showed up and the round continued as normal with power.
Now here is my conflict. I have always thought emergency shuttles should be an absolute last resort. Im talking code red situation + mass casualties and every attempt to rectify the situation has failed. Is the responsibility on the head of staff to get creative during these times? Did I overstep my authority in forcing people to play a frustrating situation? Or perhaps did I help prolong the RP a bit? My gripes where that the sole decision for an emergency shuttle rested on one person.
I want to note that this situation is must the latest, but most severe case. More and more I see heads calling emergency shuttles early because a few things go wrong. I thinks line has to be drawn somewhere. Should I just let this happen as all IC? or is it true a line does exist and if so where? I would love any and all opinions here.