MattAtlas

Appeal denied.

If you don't understand what you did wrong, this is not the board you're looking for. Ban appeals are for when you recognize what you did wrong.

On trial from 01AUG2020 to 08AUG2020.

Closing and archiving, then.

These complaints are not factored into the decision unless there is very solid proof.

So, sorry about the delay. I had trouble finding the motivation to do this, or anything at all really, in the past few weeks. We have come to the conclusion that the note is reasonable. Based on what you saw, it is reasonable to arrest somebody for questioning or a low charge, but definitely not murder or attempted murder, unless you are SURE about it. We dont really see that kind of surefire evidence here. The tone however is questionable and she will be talked to about this. Closing in 24 hours.

Well this lasted a lot longer than 7 days. Accepted.

What do you mean? Not only have no maintainers approved it, it's not even awaiting merge, and it doesn't even have 2 approvals.

The fact that me, a contributor, a 17 year old with too much time on their hands has to go through this kind of feedback post to make a simple medical change is exactly why real world parallels need to go as soon as humanely possible. Like I genuinely just have no clue what I'm reading here. It's 2462 with magic space engines for Christ's sake. I should be able to make changes without wading through paragraphs of technobabble about how "It's more realistic this way so it HAS to stay!"

I'd rather see the name changes go in than not, because I'm dead tired of real world parallels in medical and the headache that they've brought me, both when I was porting brainmed and now. If we're worried about a basis this can be fixed relatively easily by adding lore descriptions to chemicals and making them show up when you examine a bottle. That'd be my preferred approach simply because it's more about adding than changing, but I'd be fine either. As for "alienating new players", this is an excuse that's often brought up instead of "I don't like this" because it means nothing, to be honest. New players aren't actual monkeys and most of them will get used to the changes in a day or two after a few ahelps or asking in OOC. Complete exaggeration. Most chemists either use VSC or the wiki, both of which would be updated before merging the PR anyway, at which point you can just ctrl+f what you need. This, also, means nothing, because not only is it untrue, it also doesn't matter. PRs can be made by whoever for whatever reason.

It took a while to read through all the evidence compiled, I will admit, but we've reached a judgement, and it is that we can't really justify taking any action on AmShaegaar here, for a few reasons. 1. We usually do not act on what happens in DMs between players unless it is EXTREMELY egregious. What I have seen, though, does not meet that criteria. I have also not seen anything that could be construed as harassment or bypassing blocking on Discord. 2. What has actually happened on the server is either far too old to justify taking action on, or is simply not against the rules. An example of this is the round IDs we have been given. We found really no wrongdoing there, nor can we actually see any evidence of them intentionally trying to bypass a block to harass a player. All in all, what we can tell you here is to block the player in question and report harassment if it happens, immediately. This thread will be locked in 24 hours.

Accepted.

@Estoytrucha @goolie If either of you have ANY more proof, in ANY form whatsoever - screenshots or round IDs, now is the time to post it.

Not only did I port all of the things you're mentioning, I also nerfed them, and you also missed the point completely, because alcohol and toxin processing is separate.

Yeah probably needs to be nerfed a real lot.

You should be able to return livers to pre-brainmed levels I think? That should solve it, and would be easier than just buffing everything.

You have so many notes that it's unreasonable to continue warning and noting you as people have. Moreover you openly admitted to me in DMs that you broke the rules because it's funny. I'm not sure why I'd hold a grudge against you of all people, or how this can even be seen as one. About the ban, I specifically told Garnascus to handle that incident with Alberyk in DMs right as I PM'd you. I told you to stop continuing the argument so that you two would stop. Again, I didn't single you out then, and I didn't single you out now. I also find it especially egregious that you'd bring both these incidents up after you apologize for your conduct in DMs and say that you understand after.

Very good post. I'll take a look into alternative changes for stasis bags instead of what we have now. I wasn't really ever told they were this important and from my experience, they weren't.

On trial until 14/7/2020.

Kinda pointless. We're really close to getting modular computer PDAs and when we get those the ringtone has to go.

I've had to bwoink many, many trauma physicians doing surgery because the role itself is an enigma. All of them thought that due to the name they can do surgery, and they can't. It's a physician that does physician things with a different name. There's no alternate roleplay to be had here, because there's absolutely zero mechanical differences. I basically made this role, and imo, it has to go.

I think the biggest problem you've always had was just not wanting to go outside your sphere of comfort with characters. It does look like you're doing something about it, which is good in my books.

I am totally not late. By like two weeks. Nope. Accepted.

On trial from 4JUL2020 to 11JUL2020.

Fine by me. It is iffy to buff a weapon that's already retardedly strong, though.